Madden 09 is the **** with its visuals but that is about it. I had more fun playing madden 08, and i will continue to play it.
First of all, the QB's in Madden 09 are Super Accurate. Secondly, the players are very hard to tackle. All it takes is a few spin moves and your gone.
Lastly, the darn players keep running out of bounds when they should be in bounds catching the ball. This was more frequent in madden 09 then in 08.
thats my 2 cents.
visuals...madden 09
gameplay...madden 08